{
  "rule": "prereg D17: seeded random sample (seed 20261010) of 150 of the 1,082 E4 figures the script matched to a label or published value; bar 5%",
  "reader": "separate agent of the same model family, then coordinator adjudication",
  "population": 1082,
  "sample": 150,
  "firstRead": {
    "wrong": 17,
    "share": 0.1133,
    "wilson95": [
      0.072,
      0.174
    ]
  },
  "adjudicated": {
    "wrong": 12,
    "share": 0.08,
    "wilson95": [
      0.0464,
      0.1346
    ]
  },
  "verdict": "FAILS the 5% bar under either reading: the label/published split of E4 is not published as coded (D17).",
  "items": [
    {
      "id": 0,
      "sha256": "aafc5004f69d38b4a1a7e43fd5797c1864feb0b051410e6a347c0c89dee65cd0",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 1,
      "sha256": "70e050cc87cac72fb6d3c62416994a81c4275c53f9c44202c32d1b6cd69e222d",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Table row is owned by Ozempic: \"| **Ozempic (semaglutide)** | ... semaglutide weight-loss results are commonly around 15-17%\"; the row's first cell is Ozempic, so the figure is not Wegovy's.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P1"
    },
    {
      "id": 2,
      "sha256": "1b89cf831ca428f6355da9fa36b2a47154540616f41c53ad087888e5444078e1",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "963efad518bdd7c70791d7147226246e37d944245dba10e929fbbfe58a8acb08",
      "value": 10,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 3,
      "sha256": "8015e22452be18413180660cb9b83cb81b0bc457abea03afc502d8153487bcc0",
      "text": "10–15%",
      "value": 10,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... describe semaglutide-based options such as Wegovy as producing about 10–15% average body-weight loss in clinical trials, whil\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 4,
      "sha256": "a391919303e0356f54f36a7852a206cec021effea0e5f20d732ee5327caee09a",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...STEP trials, participants experienced an average weight loss of about 15% over 68–72 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 5,
      "sha256": "c406040f6dc5a8f92dd1822198078aeafb873ed0c2480f2ef27dc4bc0e2f9e61",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "8e34884546ee4dddc7ab3cc644a6cb1dea238b9b2fe9d8d5c47803457e5b0e91",
      "value": 15.8,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 6,
      "sha256": "a36d70217a9a4c130aa91218900892dace2bdb1d6d696987b492e16f93940efc",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 7,
      "sha256": "ad50888fed2dc26ad4df44cc124d1c8881d4c020441e5e17d2c9ddc08aafbe54",
      "text": "[figure beside a withheld sentence of page P61]",
      "value": null,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...[sentence S3 of withheld page P61].\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 8,
      "sha256": "7db78f320d94397902a0d2b17c5985f5f6ff4d6deabc79ed2128071008aabccb",
      "text": "10–17%",
      "value": 10,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: \"Eligible users may lose roughly 10-17% of body weight over about a year\" is a typical-range statement about Wegovy; coded as a mean range, endpoint 10 matches 9.6 (label).",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 9,
      "sha256": "56bd144bb95d4a3590b5eff8d8155c60e44819971889bd6fdf9c2a725ef3ac41",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Wegovy (semaglutide 2.4 mg, weekly) typically produces 15–17% weight loss.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 10,
      "sha256": "52c7cc890b0a139e3c1645058d082825648acd5af5c3ebfdda86658c46824268",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "21788f57e84dd2403ecb3a14145c5315f5cc29d0a74c69747c52de54c7b64358",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 11,
      "sha256": "c0216b4167666bafdc300bfdb3d34d0ba7b7651ad60ca9d92904bf70f6273b6d",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "098b1367dcb7540a7ebca4a822a8b7c7d1805596bb9bb53db24b034a2dc0c24d",
      "value": 10,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Figure sits in the Ozempic bullet: [Gemini answer text withheld]; belongs to Ozempic.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P1"
    },
    {
      "id": 12,
      "sha256": "d8b4e8dd2d70b449fbe30971ee5d3dcb789e2a7456d343d0f370273e851af290",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In trials, the highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks, compared with 11.1% over\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 13,
      "sha256": "00f751e6e73ade7402a4a0d8f27b3edd6264e788d5d52d2ebdb13c2f9c4bed8b",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...rated that Wegovy can lead to an average weight loss of approximately 15–17% of initial body weight over a 72-week period.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 14,
      "sha256": "f92b97314977c44465dcf4aed99d88520a814d4a9d9664e01147b4d7ba43e09a",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...bound is Wegovy (semaglutide), another injectable GLP-1 that produces 15% average body weight loss.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 15,
      "sha256": "923bf1cc5b931beb432abab6c26e0073cc8da388fe5e4df98354a258c7fac7e8",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In trials, the highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks, compared with 11.1% over\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 16,
      "sha256": "a36f9e2404fb5ab9d3bba528f940ebde7c9ce333bd7acdddf35085ffc3dfe63a",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 17,
      "sha256": "d50d7fc3e1c7b052ea57418ce5463892b3206d3ce9adef8d9d742d43ac5d12d8",
      "text": "16%",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In a 68-week study, people taking Wegovy lost nearly 16% of their starting weight, on average, compared wi\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 18,
      "sha256": "552a061f19eaf7ed5b7aaf3824c32b41e16a091931cb0b9c12a58756f2f001f1",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"| Effectiveness | Typically around 15–17% average weight loss in clinic/trial summaries cit\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 19,
      "sha256": "5cedfa246d0904ea43884ed1d4dd9758a668501fd3a035f8d31e2829d0229db9",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "bbcc1e5282872322fb8e39e6df1bcd0e49e0970a198bebca55ce1473ed30c498",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 20,
      "sha256": "a995a6b6824e82a5e2aa00f2225b49e740135531ca538257e1f8f26656ee218d",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In trials, the highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks, compared with 11.1% over\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 21,
      "sha256": "9154cced88d70759dd41aab48e675ff948e0ff50d6cabebcc68f7f5716791dac",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 22,
      "sha256": "958e02e83115e7ccb776e579410b985954cd937d33b4718be588dfa0606c5290",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... 4) showed that the once-daily 25 mg Wegovy pill delivered an average 17% weight loss, comparable to the injectable version\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 23,
      "sha256": "3741866dad60b4adf046d0ad8335904c022e2b0a22b38d39cd1f2d6743d13b6f",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "90c06792e6f32f565cc8f945428f1f3b6f562d5ae2a79d1b8443c40f46137ffc",
      "value": 20.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 24,
      "sha256": "31fb72155f9366ba717ca3476d541d25a8c9e15fb1ca7aba9fdcc00541d079bc",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "21788f57e84dd2403ecb3a14145c5315f5cc29d0a74c69747c52de54c7b64358",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 25,
      "sha256": "2364d8e0a7e30530857b8f302348bb33aecfa5c098ea42b533b52ab1131ed57f",
      "text": "15% to 17%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ss results: UAE reporting and trial summaries put average loss around 15% to 17% over roughly a year when taken properly.[2][3][7]\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 26,
      "sha256": "301d7d13c923ffa35cdd6968344f06a7fa6c6fd5486053d60765b05d66979702",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...LP-1 receptor agonist that has demonstrated an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks in clinical studies.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 27,
      "sha256": "8516228969041b602066068e3eea5d934bd5f0ee8bcd80824c283de65cb19127",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "d1a98093b645cb1c9fb0df8f3ec7f3831793f39a1d1486bc13dd2c205312c374",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 28,
      "sha256": "a01eb8f3d8d70c6dc37e3e8908c5dcef7164e6e7fe04c7ed660063215a3f3654",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 29,
      "sha256": "c10927d9c64ff7b12c7149c7a0d7b05b931aaa8bfe97bc8b3d7eb91dac595b51",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 30,
      "sha256": "9391e56fac1e6c6bcb50de4fb0dff342a6bf4de4661d04c5599c35a51dc0f8fd",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "a7d661af95b1113f05536ba36f66fb94ddd7eb41dcb5ba6ccdd3be235498ee92",
      "value": 13.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 31,
      "sha256": "22b8d4f80f3a7c7fe061ede196ed29d01ce7442114574c308fc35d1f2475b92b",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b5f6dbae04bd764b0c2f3cb796e404ffdf77fb4cac171d72ec7fa6a2077da252",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 32,
      "sha256": "d968662c3685b341a820695274afa9799fe4d18532b7f163b71294e077cfb301",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 33,
      "sha256": "be719084e43472c848392eff8f13624f331bb1e5591baa9c04c7303056102645",
      "text": "16%",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The Wegovy group lost an average of roughly 16% of their initial body weight.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 34,
      "sha256": "4384912f84ab10133981b836e4297f322364918d04914f512baffeeb3036e0a2",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In the STEP 1 trial, participants lost approximately 15% of body weight on average over 68 weeks when Wego\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 35,
      "sha256": "c14024500d34dcd582f394d6e19893ee842a7d346f66f3f7dc0ccd0ab3144ac5",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The once-daily 25 mg Wegovy pill delivered an average 17% weight loss, with about 1 in 3 participants achie\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 36,
      "sha256": "1989a8f08cb08b13ade7225cf0f7a972b239854c5e1c6b6c256b7abc5743a090",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 37,
      "sha256": "c7f97783a32f85df4b09d8deccab3fe6f36b39ddc8d8d81ce93f7e7cce8382c8",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "21788f57e84dd2403ecb3a14145c5315f5cc29d0a74c69747c52de54c7b64358",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 38,
      "sha256": "58d9c56c7004a5c9757733147cb91c3d45707173243f6039edb8a5d03630c760",
      "text": "10–15%",
      "value": 10,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"UAE clinic sources cite around 10–15% average loss in trials.[6] | Typically lower;\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 39,
      "sha256": "658898fe4100e87330583a8e18fe1537e356486c24e798b2e8d43f9e07d2102a",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "230bbea80616829948bc48fb46187c761173e81964ded4d38cfeabc64b02bccd",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 40,
      "sha256": "27eccbd71864c142895c3d005f2303ef9ec9ae536aaee0a76aa519b243f702f4",
      "text": "13.7%",
      "value": 13.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...an average of 20.2% of their body weight with tirzepatide compared to 13.7% with semaglutide.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 41,
      "sha256": "a5079b18784b8dedd95b9c380eb00802170ac035f568fb5e4a6cb5c8424315b5",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "d021ca4b5b49cfd966a7e258c80def3221d526d712f9f27e15fe49fd6b042f7c",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference. [Gemini answer text withheld] here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 42,
      "sha256": "981905211f12e4e309f4ac3b4e1acb1e824c325fe8db3a1bbffb2a8c8a7b4ad0",
      "text": "17 per cent",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Trial data show the oral formulation delivering around 17 per cent mean body weight reduction at 64 weeks\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 43,
      "sha256": "c725de16913cd081539e30077032a279a0fa20b2f74980dba1173278f45a2e0a",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"| Weight-loss effectiveness | Typically reported around 15–17% average weight loss | Typically reported around 5\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 44,
      "sha256": "faf07a6927deec7c544f94bf5817301771948f8c1cca6c2a184011c0fe81ff32",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "97b24cab3d48e47c11cff2598b6c26d69a6d5a834d270d8711c2e3662c310e90",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is a spread of reported individual outcomes, not a mean effect.",
      "adjudicated": "correct",
      "adjudicationNote": "Coordinator: a stated typical range for the medicine is coded endpoint by endpoint under S7, as the D4 read did for the same wording; overruled to correct."
    },
    {
      "id": 45,
      "sha256": "64b01b6045592ef35f344c4b05fcedfa64f1d7f484f2d1bfb34c197088d8c54f",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9033fa8b01c6f3dffec49ed5117268008ea0b9e41f986f9f52cc4259e5019585",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] has ceiling wording, but 16-17 equals the oral Wegovy trial mean (OASIS 4, label).",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 46,
      "sha256": "c459ead2398aaf4e6e280be41907438a93808550250fed3b5f7e63d95e82db79",
      "text": "12-15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...t loss over six months at top dose, while injectable Wegovy is around 12-15% over 12 months—new pills sit slightly below injec\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 47,
      "sha256": "cd712c646639768f2b7dce2979e186f17779be4be817980af74c2de624db8d08",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...LP-1 receptor agonist that has demonstrated an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks in clinical studies.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 48,
      "sha256": "339f19cc8a00a56621e3fc87df08ed94b556aa014e77b192a6de6bc17df2b998",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...rial, participants using Wegovy experienced an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 49,
      "sha256": "9d26a7b98c83cb83a7dec330abd4b717455a30bfefab6ef547e4ceffde86aad6",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... that semaglutide can lead to an average weight loss of approximately 17% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 50,
      "sha256": "08be24e0d7c28f2a63207e44560f03c86b05fc79f45cd845bbba43f961da5f7c",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "ec5f5cdd5c735ffe56140eb35947ff45e7804cec5f2658edc5d224fa52f32ad4",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 51,
      "sha256": "e8c801841c8644867f4f386b8d5c974fd058564470dc04574c89ef7779eacf74",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "d021ca4b5b49cfd966a7e258c80def3221d526d712f9f27e15fe49fd6b042f7c",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference. [Gemini answer text withheld] here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 52,
      "sha256": "e7000556012bd5e5788d03f73985abd4313339b39e4bf66e6f4a894ea5306937",
      "text": "13.7%",
      "value": 13.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...Zepbound leading to superior average weight loss of 20.2% compared to 13.7% with Wegovy.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 53,
      "sha256": "8aeeced58c3eacf5300e69b93a2432d8d2ed07f636546ea2528c0654ab4bf557",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "3237c22ad47ab64b1657990787c4b1777cbcd60a2b1f0ef97de9ccd434bd9792",
      "value": 19,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 54,
      "sha256": "517adef1349e46d7ac8dc5d89fe9e4edb99d0f5a14993c9c1a11c41e6a26ce82",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"| Typical weight-loss effect | About 15–17% in UAE clinic guidance and related local market r\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 55,
      "sha256": "10e649f8fec33716a9abd9cf86678c1ee4998a63f02926e34dd28198e4c79043",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "2f8d5346511f5e21d303ed1f3707a8e2f7a002b72195f578825047095b5449f9",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 56,
      "sha256": "2e9ed4de8946035193e04307f07a8bde8d85101c353bfd05268e0421dcc89d33",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "dc7aaa377133d3325148feffdfb0cec2b87184c43e00c5eaf5edc950ddf6b1a6",
      "value": 19,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 57,
      "sha256": "c60fac383f30ac21867238e5c4d0e321af8f02f268cd31791140fdf72f13018a",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "18a582e719fbf1a605e29b72fbf9c22da3b5622f1aac1abad57df0c7d4169806",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 58,
      "sha256": "4bec7e79eb73df4880f79bc778070e709c312c7877e2d47d0260186902efac2d",
      "text": "13.7%",
      "value": 13.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"| Typical weight loss in direct comparison | About 13.7% after 72 weeks | About 20.2% after 72 weeks[1] |\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 59,
      "sha256": "c9bf942bb6a6c3f3acbd8f0fda4a70e5ffbd5de081d051b550f2500edb6e17f5",
      "text": "20.7%",
      "value": 20.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... clinical trials, mean weight loss reached up to 22.5% with Zepbound, 20.7% with Wegovy HD, 16.6% with oral Wegovy, and 11.1%\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 60,
      "sha256": "eb8f6d48ef2b559c0384137b4aa57262a48a43cf07ae11cc0d6706fb6c8c7272",
      "text": "16.6%",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6% compared to Foundayo's 12.4%\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 61,
      "sha256": "856cdd44a66e89ee4af2f4615a79d179fb162939d389f67f13040187e0fe225b",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "e1042fda52bcb6900f7b403f2a43a56e7c0dfb7dbc41d6cbd295c65ed83fedb0",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is frequency wording about users, not a stated mean.",
      "adjudicated": "correct",
      "adjudicationNote": "Coordinator: a stated typical range for the medicine is coded endpoint by endpoint under S7, as the D4 read did for the same wording; overruled to correct."
    },
    {
      "id": 62,
      "sha256": "661bbbcf7b7eb92eabb4ba46d5c98719c897d813e3a63fbb4869406d8c5272a1",
      "text": "16.6%",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...s have demonstrated significant weight loss, with reductions of up to 16.6% of body weight.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 63,
      "sha256": "5bab6b9f8397dba4d1edc848bc87bbc6a767b6a616af1375a62db78c4cb094fe",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Clinical trials have shown an average weight loss of approximately 15% over 68 weeks when combined with a reduced-calori\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 64,
      "sha256": "c5d9bc7e4f8f6102b86ece43cfb53ca25216f8beb6de82ddfb03fde7c81d516b",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... available in the UAE, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 65,
      "sha256": "95bc837d3efd23d8c45a817382d551eab0a9fe12f1743eb0bae49e3a2581f69e",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b5f6dbae04bd764b0c2f3cb796e404ffdf77fb4cac171d72ec7fa6a2077da252",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] under the Wegovy bullet; read as the average 15% (label 14.9).",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 66,
      "sha256": "a9fd72374f9cb123c58b0a1514d871ca4e65e69945cd1bafbf3e7c5569ea7910",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b32c7c02d5358d803e37a6ab5c611503133f6cdd0b3027ffa77f756078f09bb6",
      "value": 19,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is ceiling wording, but 19 equals the 7.2 mg Wegovy trial mean (label 18.8).",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 67,
      "sha256": "761af2854fc493e4441f4307facb81a427d9ef89d39a5a66ae50e124bc6edbf0",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 68,
      "sha256": "2c486eae0c0fd7da6ee59958ea2d0e6d722a1526ec10b9a95e766f6109b943be",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 69,
      "sha256": "85c012918d5461b366146a7b6242e27cd49550f63d7c52b431cfb5ad964d2f5a",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Saxenda users lost closer to 8% of body weight compared to Wegovy's 15%\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 70,
      "sha256": "81a7a85ef9785021362b7132d089c3ff52bb85bbad70876370ad2c410d78d7af",
      "text": "13.6% to 17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...a shortcut: clinical trial results cited in UAE coverage show roughly 13.6% to 17% average weight loss with oral Wegovy depending on\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 71,
      "sha256": "1dedb1fc47aecebd030eb93d7f82f9c5548f1a09b7e0d59c3fad64828de92301",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference. [Gemini answer text withheld] here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 72,
      "sha256": "12af4750fd1a9531babd090288720df64b8a780501e0e71da70e570e0f0b7943",
      "text": "14%",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Zepbound produced approximately 20% average weight loss versus 14% with Wegovy in a direct comparison, although indi\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 73,
      "sha256": "fe2b3628c1803d6f4200e62f65da2c1ceee24a79c111f0dac3bd5c6fdd6ffa30",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...hat oral semaglutide 25 mg taken once daily can lead to approximately 17% mean weight loss in adults with obesity or overwe\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 74,
      "sha256": "4b293a3d3da82a5b2c539f3b4d45b751fcc1b7db199bd988f09da56727c227fc",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "ec5f5cdd5c735ffe56140eb35947ff45e7804cec5f2658edc5d224fa52f32ad4",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is framed as what some patients reach (S5 [Gemini answer text withheld]), although the numbers equal trial means.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "M2"
    },
    {
      "id": 75,
      "sha256": "6e1718898279970bd497a22cf1fb3ceb917c45fe95dbcb098a013e162af00767",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide[Gemini answer text withheld]initial body weight.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 76,
      "sha256": "80c7a6718b351d12fe392ec610727be98736753da14d9191d3bd1d2f36a69caf",
      "text": "12–15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: \"Semaglutide alternatives ... average 12-15% reduction\" follows a sentence naming both Wegovy and Ozempic, but the figure's own sentence says semaglutide for weight loss; label 14.9.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 77,
      "sha256": "1a5aa3cde6385e90100177229e2f3f6e97e68ab565bd047128168c2f24714a3a",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 78,
      "sha256": "00d6a99a30fbf4deaf4efd7048fc123ebb5b73a1ec2c1ce420e4e829f8c10961",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 79,
      "sha256": "68f159cccb4ec41f986e992dbca0072b7d58c8e3e1dfd2e303670fe6b9cab628",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 80,
      "sha256": "48b85f5fc49760d3dc8e4da89e4c126bdfde2af68af882f1d6400b697ba264b7",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In trials, the highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks, compared with 11.1% over\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 81,
      "sha256": "fcfc3975f4c34077572d1a4c41a41546f051d287a21160005f229ea7df6eac80",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 82,
      "sha256": "39feb4cffafce1f224e93cb40216ab474f0b6ad4553733a628a24af02b27b056",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Studies indicate an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 83,
      "sha256": "17f73f41cffba22491e570dfbd58abdf0f0892170b45d88e5cf945912cda7834",
      "text": "15 to 20%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Heading names \"Semaglutide (Ozempic, Wegovy) and Tirzepatide (Mounjaro)\"; \"15 to 20%\" is owned jointly by the whole GLP-1 group, not Wegovy alone.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 84,
      "sha256": "faf07a6927deec7c544f94bf5817301771948f8c1cca6c2a184011c0fe81ff32",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "12dbf428e1b8dad5fb3c713c26ca8f10e99cd2ffef9b61584223a318101e5b7c",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 85,
      "sha256": "5b250d268d9fd1dcb413ba2e04d0754fa3c15259e125f060c48342e7b9433d30",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b5f6dbae04bd764b0c2f3cb796e404ffdf77fb4cac171d72ec7fa6a2077da252",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 86,
      "sha256": "6a996577164c273fb636b512d3006abc51a3af5c25d6b76a79de2d6f2b457c71",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "uncertain: \"some participants achieving an average reduction of approximately 15%\" has minority wording but states an average for Wegovy (label 14.9).",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 87,
      "sha256": "c2baa6c9ece3d7bb0317f0394bd089ca1570fc6294dc4fd18d2e117dca5772db",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The once-daily 25 mg Wegovy pill delivered an average 17% weight loss, with about 1 in 3 participants achie\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 88,
      "sha256": "41c8075823ba5189677f25ba249a17ee9f4096ea3d6020d6d46f2f95c53f89eb",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 89,
      "sha256": "455368011429743621adf63a7a89f67a05178216deceaf6d5de3716dec9383f3",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "659de863ddbe567a1827e66b470a8958d01529a41932c093977f98514e38499c",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 90,
      "sha256": "7b29b2424e2e1b674a03aeb3f8370518c420e2ed2be0c1a3d4b957a3fac9aab2",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "011fbf3abc7043355d50c4f6f69823197a09349fe2991eb932bcacbf536e5a4f",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 91,
      "sha256": "17cb6e698bf66d6ab10a44489401726a51991ad59e6ab1d7a54374a27018a352",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 92,
      "sha256": "0c0389ad6a09e0ad90c0dfb8ac6b7b03e66c8b575c309b3437137c0975a63742",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "cef3aa4553f9db9e5724e78f50bb73647d61b3523e7df6d578b02ab23612f480",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 93,
      "sha256": "dfc6f8d87d8ab386fd1a853cb50773dd3536d39e81325f774bd2e458042fa4bb",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...l trials showed the once-daily 25 mg Wegovy pill delivered an average 17% weight loss, with about 1 in 3 participants achie\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 94,
      "sha256": "c3bcb8739778e14e86e8c4a03eea49a6fdc3f364ea1098918b8123976414c5ca",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ss, with participants achieving an average reduction of approximately 15% of their body weight over a 14-month period.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 95,
      "sha256": "f29f412f10e34b98e4c9715463b8670dc630f128f5134f5a09552ef1701ee0e3",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "cef3aa4553f9db9e5724e78f50bb73647d61b3523e7df6d578b02ab23612f480",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 96,
      "sha256": "06e1e3dc4be9e0b34f5ba8215aa216f0acda670504d107569b9c4697304d5ad2",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Clinical trials have demonstrated an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 97,
      "sha256": "46da616284c8b08a898a375392d00325037597ec1e448bc55ce62c1c36e9051a",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Under the line \"1. Ozempic (Semaglutide):\" the efficacy bullet gives 14.9% over 68 weeks; the subject of the line is Ozempic, not Wegovy (Wegovy is item 2).",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P1"
    },
    {
      "id": 98,
      "sha256": "44e500b4b90453a8230a8cf872684d67ff9e94d279511b0261451bee351e9e1c",
      "text": "5–15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Generic expectation timeline (\"Around 6 months: roughly 5-15% loss is plausible depending on treatment intensity\"); not tied to Wegovy and not a trial mean.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "M2"
    },
    {
      "id": 99,
      "sha256": "0139b5ce7f6fddbd3df3bfe67701e4cc7df2f8057f6c5f4cff9b5643865f573a",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Semaglutide produces an average 14.9% body weight loss over 68 weeks in the STEP 1 tria\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 100,
      "sha256": "4eefd5665e224a087005c818883d473237142978bc447bf2073ad580e48bbd89",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Oral Wegovy reduces body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 101,
      "sha256": "1989a8f08cb08b13ade7225cf0f7a972b239854c5e1c6b6c256b7abc5743a090",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "8b3f50661b3d9e97013eb77484c24acceaa39670283e7cac78831bc273d049f2",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 102,
      "sha256": "e2f58d5589e73e01c471ef262c8d5e2badde028c2ce586b285970a19875ccf8f",
      "text": "16.6%",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6% compared to Foundayo's 12.4%.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 103,
      "sha256": "6ff4302d8e24d2e81ee5905777766ab55d591b31e91f02c13b8eb63451d420de",
      "text": "13.7%",
      "value": 13.7,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...t loss than Wegovy, with an average weight loss of 20.02% compared to 13.7% with Wegovy.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 104,
      "sha256": "b8b3a200acc9c89fc61c492cda76f3c372d9fe1b3fa20e0f735695ff2b11e5d3",
      "text": "16.6%",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ral form reduces body weight by 12.4% compared to injectable Wegovy's 16.6%.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 105,
      "sha256": "d79760c09df66cd5d7d886d2bb2afaa77d47db0615ea1f16a3ef216a98307834",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "963efad518bdd7c70791d7147226246e37d944245dba10e929fbbfe58a8acb08",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "[Gemini answer text withheld] then [Gemini answer text withheld]; joint Wegovy/Mounjaro ownership, plus a [Gemini answer text withheld] ceiling.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 106,
      "sha256": "f2f9f5d5e263733574e7e253dfd2b51faa30239948109d9295f2ce2601b009bd",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Studies indicate an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 107,
      "sha256": "a962e68a56439820d4a87e616f71fc0be9ad12efc40ab1a5a8872b9fa4d4ec2a",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: \"up to 15% body-weight loss with semaglutide-class therapy\" inside a GLP-1/GIP marketing sentence: class wording plus an 'up to' ceiling, not a Wegovy mean.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 108,
      "sha256": "396df2db5366de0eced02af539cb4f178f460a73cccc947d495a5dfe09242a09",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ment, Wegovy has demonstrated an average weight loss of approximately 14.9% over 68 weeks in clinical trials.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 109,
      "sha256": "47692f4f92754b29a34e61bee58f5760fda0972c548ecc528474e7893b3b67be",
      "text": "15 kg",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...2.8 kg) of body weight compared with Wegovy users who averaged 13.7% (15 kg) loss.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 110,
      "sha256": "fa09e76d85360eeb69b1d5aea23ee59bd6e857fd337e9875176ba3aa043dd1f5",
      "text": "13.6%–16.6%",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"UAE reporting on the pill notes about 13.6%–16.6% average body-weight reduction in clinical tests.[\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 111,
      "sha256": "5ec936021dc1eb279473de1e14bcfe70a158085ea56c69c5c27693282a480e27",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "97b24cab3d48e47c11cff2598b6c26d69a6d5a834d270d8711c2e3662c310e90",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is a typical-outcome range, not a mean effect.",
      "adjudicated": "correct",
      "adjudicationNote": "Coordinator: a stated typical range for the medicine is coded endpoint by endpoint under S7, as the D4 read did for the same wording; overruled to correct."
    },
    {
      "id": 112,
      "sha256": "c481747f8d68046fef3c5fe8e3fcc447ef9ec51b6a3a2e60db852e3eef21bae8",
      "text": "15 to 20%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Sentence follows \"semaglutide (Ozempic, Wegovy) ... and tirzepatide (Mounjaro)\"; \"15 to 20%\" is a joint class figure incl. Mounjaro, not Wegovy alone.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 113,
      "sha256": "60d0062ba7254b6317c7a294dec5e0c1acab8955371b1e0f92a984a88de06d1f",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "278fa470becc74371a93e3a4284e420075a7ee8ce7a4beaeffb123e5bd29921e",
      "value": 21,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 114,
      "sha256": "1c558b78961e36b3c83d4974673f90d2c19891b47f19448c6199ac7763251405",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... 4) showed that the once-daily 25 mg Wegovy pill delivered an average 17% weight loss, comparable to the injectable version\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 115,
      "sha256": "93ca611c8bc3d64ee70329157b53d62247900fee0311ace2c3d0f2275ac23886",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "3732c82a843f69bd5611819dd0d891c4ac11306a1ef1a630fdaf95b622db8551",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "Bullet is [Gemini answer text withheld]; joint class figure and an [Gemini answer text withheld] ceiling.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 116,
      "sha256": "abd244b1b3b053e8a679f03b7437d61d57a46e47b6fae1fe4bcd7ff6cb00656d",
      "text": "12 to 15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Wegovy achieves around 12 to 15% weight loss over 12 months when paired with lifes\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 117,
      "sha256": "c406040f6dc5a8f92dd1822198078aeafb873ed0c2480f2ef27dc4bc0e2f9e61",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "18a582e719fbf1a605e29b72fbf9c22da3b5622f1aac1abad57df0c7d4169806",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 118,
      "sha256": "d9eac0f757f7f5438820f4da55f7f65ec679e1dbd9b5f9694234c2cffe5c216b",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "21788f57e84dd2403ecb3a14145c5315f5cc29d0a74c69747c52de54c7b64358",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 119,
      "sha256": "3b19248fff2656b8664c3aedc443350ee4f9fd0fb6f1bde63f4fe703abca40c1",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 120,
      "sha256": "6ff4302d8e24d2e81ee5905777766ab55d591b31e91f02c13b8eb63451d420de",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...remain more effective, with oral Wegovy reducing body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 121,
      "sha256": "722498c69507a9effccf4b1e6a60600f6780b478ac9449f0dcdcbc81041e1eae",
      "text": "16%",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The Wegovy group lost an average of roughly 16% of their initial body weight.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 122,
      "sha256": "a01654d787b883cd8d015a8cbea4ad6e1892e9622430e43539e81379b4263819",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "d1a98093b645cb1c9fb0df8f3ec7f3831793f39a1d1486bc13dd2c205312c374",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 123,
      "sha256": "c66b6d9bf12d50cbc0c2028802103c454e48aad29dc6afff42f09ccd53b9494c",
      "text": "16%",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...6% weight loss over 68 weeks, while semaglutide (Wegovy) led to about 16% weight loss.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 124,
      "sha256": "b5982c4c6e416ad9b6d1e3e874ecbb8f8c8be74dedd4fa6434c36d115ffd994b",
      "text": "16%",
      "value": 16,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"In a 68-week study, people taking Wegovy lost nearly 16% of their starting weight, on average, compared wi\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 125,
      "sha256": "5a8990840792fbcfa0c44bf0c03a128328217ebf8b3b41783dbdcaa806058f41",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 126,
      "sha256": "d9eac0f757f7f5438820f4da55f7f65ec679e1dbd9b5f9694234c2cffe5c216b",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "cf874200f0ed651fae4a43a74e842056eeeab6be28633d07be6a05a995514708",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 127,
      "sha256": "b0c115091a9ec428b4b53ed19d668233ffcbe345b8c3e30a8efe37e7a6e07554",
      "text": "14.9%",
      "value": 14.9,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Studies indicate an average weight loss of 14.9% over 68 weeks.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 128,
      "sha256": "0d4e99afb69b4e71a39fe96a24a60ab66ffd640447fe8eaa3ab98035b53e076d",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b5f6dbae04bd764b0c2f3cb796e404ffdf77fb4cac171d72ec7fa6a2077da252",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference. [Gemini answer text withheld] here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 129,
      "sha256": "72fc86d9acf52f6b33c832c3a30806018bde724c6c4770e632729be1b6bc7720",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "c58a80ae31062f14fa4e8d18afe2de8980a70f046c1ab2815e6f6d049b9dc836",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 130,
      "sha256": "d398b958e9391e20bf960dd5eb2c035d18fc2c59d35be7b2b7b29a14a9faa00a",
      "text": "13.6%",
      "value": 13.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"The highest 25mg Wegovy pill achieved about 13.6% weight loss in 64 weeks\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 131,
      "sha256": "1c1e64005f3b1b6e4e0a9bac9a62d41fcb0ff747e050f106c989d7fb62dd2410",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "c17dfaee734cf394a7840a9d3794b33153fcca2e1030b6de7f901c634f575b99",
      "value": 19,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 132,
      "sha256": "3063bec2f0c95474d2785a1edc07167849990a9c898c7fc806c149cc33c0df26",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "97b24cab3d48e47c11cff2598b6c26d69a6d5a834d270d8711c2e3662c310e90",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is a typical-outcome range, not a mean effect.",
      "adjudicated": "correct",
      "adjudicationNote": "Coordinator: a stated typical range for the medicine is coded endpoint by endpoint under S7, as the D4 read did for the same wording; overruled to correct."
    },
    {
      "id": 133,
      "sha256": "75a24dab9f56c46fbef9c9e0610b5f83a1dea4df1a154c7ef365f88c0f01d6ce",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"... OASIS 4 trial, oral semaglutide 25 mg taken once daily demonstrated ~17% mean weight loss, and the weight loss achieved wi\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 134,
      "sha256": "9c54c657384637949eaafb3878749c7d0ad53b7555baad09ec9d8fa610e55be8",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ss, with participants achieving an average reduction of approximately 17% of their body weight.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 135,
      "sha256": "a5c06c27b8e7ba9b317dfcc89772b0f1b6accda39f60dde893e283d20c3320b7",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "e79e376ada7fe434917ca7d7642e9e75811ae98f6da2e8bb5cfc04b6020ee1ec",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 136,
      "sha256": "82aa93d732c4181cd21afdb859b2f4ce5486045332ccef1177089386328f1e42",
      "text": "12 to 15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...s over six months at the top dose, and Wegovy (semaglutide) at around 12 to 15% over 12 months when paired with lifestyle support\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 137,
      "sha256": "e0e0de5d93ce6b935ac5d4146b2522a620aab7c7e945790eef2a6b3398b62428",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...rated that Wegovy can lead to an average weight loss of approximately 15% of initial body weight over 68 weeks when combine\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 138,
      "sha256": "aea18b90d95b13c9bec3a779db3379067199288f83ab9ba444e146ea37ec6196",
      "text": "15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: the sentence sits under a heading naming \"semaglutide (Ozempic, Wegovy) and tirzepatide (Mounjaro)\"; on S6 the subject is the joint group (the content resembles STEP 1, but the rule excludes it).",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "P3"
    },
    {
      "id": 139,
      "sha256": "7b0f69d156a58972575104533dca38bf385532e7846ea4bb7bd0d129a1582b9c",
      "text": "17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...onstrated that Wegovy can lead to a mean weight loss of approximately 17% of body weight.\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 140,
      "sha256": "be8e01facefd58279787014105005d517ff0374f8bef679b0f60d038d1cfc98a",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "9ff68d1fb292cbc96dca1d6f63353538176ff2bd5ec29c468ffa45da65a135fc",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 141,
      "sha256": "384809d04cc09a3c7654ae64ddcb1b60986f58bc28cdb4820a5196595c27a28f",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"oral Wegovy reduces body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent.\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 142,
      "sha256": "12af4750fd1a9531babd090288720df64b8a780501e0e71da70e570e0f0b7943",
      "text": "14%",
      "value": 14,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"| Average weight loss | About 14% in the standard-dose head-to-head comparison[4] |\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 143,
      "sha256": "f93c2022f68df41e6b1fc0caf291da83dea4136c8a9632afd35024805b30815f",
      "text": "16.6 per cent",
      "value": 16.6,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"Oral Wegovy reduces body weight by up to 16.6 per cent compared to Foundayo's 12.4 per cent\"; value matches a label reference. 'Up to' here qualifies a stated trial mean, not a minority, so it is coded.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 144,
      "sha256": "86de169f46335eb12f43db42148d2492882dad8076b288b89a01f43ba270f361",
      "text": "12–15%",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"semaglutide delivers average body weight reduction of 12–15%\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 145,
      "sha256": "4ae87ede30bd66485cd1b31c18ecdc01a1f99bea0d506ec1b9be7c150947f98a",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "b5f6dbae04bd764b0c2f3cb796e404ffdf77fb4cac171d72ec7fa6a2077da252",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is a responder-proportion framing, not a plain mean.",
      "adjudicated": "wrong-attribution",
      "reason": "M1"
    },
    {
      "id": 146,
      "sha256": "982fc737ab6eb0f0d62270d754960b4b7e99f6d4155cdc7dff1ba52768906160",
      "text": "15–17%",
      "value": 17,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ight loss than Saxenda, with Saxenda around 5–8% versus Wegovy around 15–17% in cited summaries.[13]\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 147,
      "sha256": "b44bf6501daa9bd4c38be816d9d153c0659afa588d51b4cbad5c5c09d100aded",
      "text": "15.8%",
      "value": 15.8,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: \"...ook Saxenda lost 6.4% of their body weight over 68 weeks, compared to 15.8% with Wegovy\"; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 148,
      "sha256": "db3340aff8c956c15f7a747e2867b441a6370ee79d4ec1cbae109da90f6bd1ac",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "18a582e719fbf1a605e29b72fbf9c22da3b5622f1aac1abad57df0c7d4169806",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "correct",
      "note": "Mean effect of Wegovy/semaglutide: [Gemini answer text withheld]; value matches a label reference.",
      "adjudicated": "correct"
    },
    {
      "id": 149,
      "sha256": "06a8b47965adfc57c6b2c549da160846fbf62b9f27b10a6df3d1667408849c1a",
      "text": "[Gemini figure text withheld]",
      "textSha256": "97b24cab3d48e47c11cff2598b6c26d69a6d5a834d270d8711c2e3662c310e90",
      "value": 15,
      "verdict": "wrong-attribution",
      "note": "uncertain: [Gemini answer text withheld] is a typical-outcome range, not a mean effect.",
      "adjudicated": "correct",
      "adjudicationNote": "Coordinator: a stated typical range for the medicine is coded endpoint by endpoint under S7, as the D4 read did for the same wording; overruled to correct."
    }
  ],
  "reasonCodes": {
    "P1": "different product, molecule or intervention",
    "P2": "comparator effect attributed to the target product",
    "P3": "joint or class-level figure without valid brand attribution",
    "M1": "responder proportion mistaken for a mean effect",
    "M2": "maximum, subgroup or illustrative result mistaken for a mean effect",
    "S1": "incorrect congress-source association",
    "O1": "other S5 exclusion (BMI value, price)",
    "U1": "insufficient evidence to verify attribution"
  }
}