{ "$schema": "./evidence-authority-standard-v1.schema.json#/$defs/testVectorFile", "title": "Test vectors for the Evidence-Authority Standard, version 3.0", "standard": { "version": "3.0", "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23594909", "conceptDoi": "10.5281/zenodo.23577316" }, "vectorsVersion": "3.0.0", "conformance": "An implementation conforms when it reproduces every test vector: for each, the claim's date, the verdict, the deciding rule (a step of the companion's decisionProcedure) and, where the vector states them, what a P3d settlement says (settledAs) and the step that fixed the claim's market, with whether a later step conflicted (market). Each input is judged with the authorities table below and with markets read as ISO 3166-1 codes, or ISO 3166-2 codes for a place below the country (a place with both is read as its ISO 3166-2 code). Vectors EAS-V001 to EAS-V068 keep their 1.0 ids; those whose expected verdict changed in 2.0 say so in a note. Version 2.1 added and changed no vector. Version 3.0 changes EAS-V044, EAS-V050 and EAS-V057, each with a note, and adds EAS-V094 to EAS-V126. Annex B, sharpened before the release of 3.0, adds EAS-V127 to EAS-V161; it changes no expected verdict of an earlier vector, and changes the claim notes of EAS-V105 and EAS-V109, each with a note.", "inputs": "Inputs use only facts published in the standard, in Field Note 07 or in Paper No. 01. Any claim, source or authority fact that is not is marked \"synthetic\": true and says why in its note.", "authorities": { "ae_ede": { "name": "Emirates Drug Establishment", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "issues": [ "authorisation_decision", "register_entry", "authorised_label" ], "basis": "Section 4, P1: the Emirates Drug Establishment's announcement is its own record of an authorisation decision, its directory lists registrations, and P1 is settled by the competent authority's authorisation decision, register entry or authorised label for that market." }, "ae_dha": { "name": "Dubai Health Authority", "jurisdictions": [ "AE-DU" ], "issues": [ "institutional_guidance" ], "basis": "Rule 6: bodies that do not authorise medicines, such as the Dubai Health Authority, issue guidance. Annex B, M1 and M6 (version 3.0): naming a body whose remit is part of a country states that part; the Dubai Health Authority states Dubai, AE-DU." }, "us_fda": { "name": "US Food and Drug Administration", "jurisdictions": [ "US" ], "issues": [ "authorisation_decision", "authorised_label" ], "basis": "Section 4, P1 and P2: the FDA is a foreign regulator for a UAE or Saudi claim; the Tzield prescribing information is its authorised label." }, "eu_ec": { "name": "European Commission", "jurisdictions": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE", "IS", "LI", "NO" ], "issues": [ "authorisation_decision", "authorised_label" ], "basis": "Section 2 and Rule 4: the Commission decides, and EU bodies speak for the 27 member states and for Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway; section 4, P1: the summary of product characteristics is Annex I to the Commission's decision." }, "eu_ema": { "name": "European Medicines Agency", "jurisdictions": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE", "IS", "LI", "NO" ], "issues": [ "regulatory_opinion", "safety_signal_record" ], "basis": "Rule 4 and section 2: the EMA recommends; the Commission decides; an EMA \"authorisation\" does not exist. Its pharmacovigilance committee assesses safety signals, and its signal records are safety signal records (P8c, version 3.0)." }, "sa_sfda": { "name": "Saudi Food and Drug Authority", "jurisdictions": [ "SA" ], "issues": [ "authorised_label", "regulator_safety_communication" ], "basis": "Section 4, P8: a label the Saudi Food and Drug Authority authorised, and its safety communications." }, "sa_chi": { "name": "Council of Health Insurance (Saudi Arabia)", "jurisdictions": [ "SA" ], "issues": [ "payer_decision" ], "basis": "Section 4, P6a (version 3.0): a payer's coverage decision for its own market.", "synthetic": true, "note": "Which decisions the Council issues, and their reach, are this file's assumptions for testing; no published fact of the standard rests on them." } }, "vectors": [ { "id": "EAS-V001", "title": "The EDE's announcement of 1 June 2026 settles a UAE approval claim", "basis": [ "section 4, P1, example", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V002", "title": "The Dubai Health Authority document supports a UAE registration claim and settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P1, example", "Rule 6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "R6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Dubai Health Authority document of 3 September 2024 (\"Approved by FDA and registered for obesity pharmacotherapy in UAE\")", "evidenceClass": "institutional_guidance", "authority": "ae_dha", "effectiveFrom": "2024-09-03", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V003", "title": "An FDA approval is a foreign regulator's record for a UAE claim: a declared benchmark", "basis": [ "section 4, P1, example (\"the FDA is a foreign regulator\")", "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US FDA approval of the injection", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2021-06-04", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The approval date is synthetic: neither publication states it." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V004", "title": "The Dubai Health Authority cited as issuing an authorisation decision: it issues guidance, which may support P1", "basis": [ "section 2, Authority", "Rule 6", "section 6, Supports" ], "illustrates": [ "R6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "An \"authorisation decision\" attributed to the Dubai Health Authority", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_dha", "effectiveFrom": "2024-09-03", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "S2-authority" } }, { "id": "EAS-V005", "title": "The EDE directory copy, whose currency is evidenced only to 5 October, cannot settle a claim of 14 October", "basis": [ "section 4, P1, example", "Rule 3" ], "illustrates": [ "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: the injection, registered 14 November 2022, as recorded on 2 and 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2022-11-14", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "Registration date and reading as section 4 (P1) reports them. currentAsOf is synthetic: the latest date the directory copy is taken to vouch for, the day of the 5 October read. Whether the value was read correctly is another step (section 8); Field Note 07 could not re-read it on 19 October 2026." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V006", "title": "\"As of October 2023\": the EDE's announcement of 1 June 2026 cannot speak to that date", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example", "section 2, the claim's date", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2023-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2023-10", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V007", "title": "\"As of October 2023\": only the injection's directory registration date could speak to that date", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example", "section 2, the claim's date", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "The standard decides from the metadata supplied. The text says this record 'could' speak to the date: Field Note 07 could not re-read the value on 19 October 2026, and whether it was read correctly belongs to another step (section 8).", "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2023-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: the injection, registered 14 November 2022, as recorded on 2 and 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2022-11-14", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "Registration date and reading as section 4 (P1) reports them. currentAsOf is synthetic: the latest date the directory copy is taken to vouch for, the day of the 5 October read. Whether the value was read correctly is another step (section 8); Field Note 07 could not re-read it on 19 October 2026." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2023-10", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V008", "title": "The directory read of 19 October 2026 found no entry for Wegovy: that read decided nothing", "basis": [ "Rule 3, example", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "R3", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-19", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim dated the day of the read, so that the vector reaches Rule 3." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory read of 19 October 2026: 1,179 products, no entry for either form of Wegovy", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "not_listed", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-19", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-19", "synthetic": true, "note": "A read that found nothing has no registration date; the read's own date stands in for it so that the vector reaches Rule 3." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-19", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V009", "title": "The same empty read with no date recorded decides nothing under Rule 7", "basis": [ "Rule 7", "Rule 3, example" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-19", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim dated the day of the read." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory read of 19 October 2026, recorded with no date", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "not_listed", "effectiveFrom": null, "currency": "not_assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-19", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V010", "title": "Teplizumab: the US label does not settle a Saudi indication claim", "basis": [ "section 4, P2, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V011", "title": "Teplizumab: the EU product information (Teizeild) does not settle a Saudi indication claim", "basis": [ "section 4, P2, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Teizeild product information annexed to the European Commission's authorisation of 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V012", "title": "Teizeild: the European Commission's authorisation of 8 January 2026 settles an EU authorisation claim", "basis": [ "section 4, P2, example", "Rule 4" ], "illustrates": [ "R4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 8 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V013", "title": "An EMA opinion supports an EU authorisation claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "Rule 4" ], "illustrates": [ "R4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 8 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EMA (CHMP) opinion on Teizeild", "evidenceClass": "regulatory_opinion", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-14", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The opinion's date is synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V014", "title": "An \"authorisation\" attributed to the EMA does not exist: what the EMA issues may only support", "basis": [ "section 2, Authority", "Rule 4", "section 6, Supports" ], "illustrates": [ "R4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 8 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "An \"authorisation decision\" attributed to the EMA", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "S2-authority" } }, { "id": "EAS-V015", "title": "A foreign label not yet in force on the claim's date is irrelevant, not a benchmark: time is checked first", "basis": [ "section 1", "section 6, Irrelevant", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-03-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Saudi claim dated before the June 2026 revision." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-03-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V016", "title": "A label revision dated only to June 2026 cannot be shown in force on 15 June 2026", "basis": [ "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-06-15", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim dated inside the month of the revision." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-06-15", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V017", "title": "Teplizumab: a media summary supports a safety finding at most (P8b)", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "The answer repeated reported adverse effects from real-world courses: a claim that the medicine is associated with them, a safety finding (P8b).", "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Media round-up on the first real-world teplizumab courses in Europe", "evidenceClass": "secondary_commentary", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The round-up's date is synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V018", "title": "A label the Saudi Food and Drug Authority authorised would settle a Saudi regulatory safety statement (P8a)", "basis": [ "section 4, P8a, example" ], "illustrates": [ "P8a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "SFDA-authorised label (hypothetical: Paper No. 01 did not establish teplizumab's Saudi registration)", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "sa_sfda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-15", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V019", "title": "A systematic review settles a safety finding as international evidence (P8b)", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b, example" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Systematic review of teplizumab safety (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "systematic_review", "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V020", "title": "One country's authority never settles a claim about the Gulf states together", "basis": [ "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "AE", "BH", "KW", "OM", "QA", "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim about the six Gulf Cooperation Council states together." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "SFDA-authorised label (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "sa_sfda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-15", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V021", "title": "Retatrutide: a registry record supports P3 and settles nothing alone (P3 is composite)", "basis": [ "section 4, P3, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Trial registry record of an interventional retatrutide study", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2023-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study and its registration date are synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V022", "title": "P3 is composite: an authorised label alone neither settles nor supports it", "basis": [ "section 4, P3" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "UAE authorised label (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-04-02", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "P3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V023", "title": "P3a: the registry record settles that the trial is registered, as international evidence", "basis": [ "section 4, P3a" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3a", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Trial registry record of an interventional retatrutide study", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2023-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study and its registration date are synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V024", "title": "Orforglipron: the EDE directory registration settles P1", "basis": [ "section 4, P3, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: orforglipron registered from 2 April 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2026-04-02", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-02", "note": "Paper No. 01 established UAE status only to 2 October 2026, so the copy is taken to vouch for its currency to that date." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V025", "title": "Orforglipron: the registration does not settle an indication claim (a register's category is not an indication)", "basis": [ "section 4, P2", "Rule 3" ], "illustrates": [ "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: orforglipron registered from 2 April 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2026-04-02", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-02", "note": "Paper No. 01 established UAE status only to 2 October 2026, so the copy is taken to vouch for its currency to that date." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V026", "title": "Orforglipron: the registration settles P1 only, not that it is investigational", "basis": [ "section 4, P3, example" ], "illustrates": [ "P3", "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026, within the period to which Paper No. 01 established UAE status." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: orforglipron registered from 2 April 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2026-04-02", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-02", "note": "Paper No. 01 established UAE status only to 2 October 2026, so the copy is taken to vouch for its currency to that date." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "P3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V027", "title": "Orforglipron: the directory copy cannot settle a claim dated after 2 October 2026", "basis": [ "Rule 3", "section 4, P3, example" ], "illustrates": [ "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 10 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: orforglipron registered from 2 April 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2026-04-02", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-02", "note": "Paper No. 01 established UAE status only to 2 October 2026, so the copy is taken to vouch for its currency to that date." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-10", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V028", "title": "P3b: the registry record version in force on the date asked settles the design", "basis": [ "section 4, P3b" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3b", "claim": { "market": null, "answerDate": "2025-06-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A design claim dated 1 June 2025; trial claims are international." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record version 1, in force until an amendment of 1 March 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2025-01-15", "effectiveTo": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2025-06-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V029", "title": "P3b: a later amendment cannot rewrite an earlier registration", "basis": [ "section 4, P3b", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3b", "claim": { "market": null, "answerDate": "2025-06-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A design claim dated 1 June 2025." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record version 2, the amendment of 1 March 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2025-06-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V030", "title": "A named guideline settles a guideline claim within its own scope; the claim's market does not govern", "basis": [ "section 4, P4, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P4", "claim": { "market": [ "SG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Singapore answer that names the guideline, dated 5 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "2022 ADA/EASD consensus report on type 2 diabetes", "evidenceClass": "clinical_guideline", "effectiveFrom": "2022", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-05", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V031", "title": "A systematic review supports a guideline claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P4" ], "illustrates": [ "P4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P4", "claim": { "market": [ "SG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Singapore answer that names the guideline, dated 5 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Systematic review of SGLT2 inhibition (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "systematic_review", "effectiveFrom": "2025-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-05", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V032", "title": "Bracketing: listings of 13 and 16 October support, and do not settle, that the chain listed Wegovy on 14 October", "basis": [ "section 4, P5, example", "Rule 7", "section 6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "Version 2.0: a listing settles only on its own date; two listings that bracket the claim's date support and never settle.", "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-14, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V033", "title": "Bracketing: listings of 13 and 16 October support, and do not settle, that the chain listed Wegovy on 15 October", "basis": [ "section 4, P5, example", "Rule 7", "section 6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "Version 2.0: a listing settles only on its own date; two listings that bracket the claim's date support and never settle.", "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-15", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-15, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-15", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V034", "title": "A listing settles on its own date: 13 October", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V035", "title": "A listing settles on its own date: 16 October", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-16", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-16, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-16", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V036", "title": "One listing alone is not in force on another day", "basis": [ "Rule 7", "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-14, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V037", "title": "A pharmacy listing only supports a claim that the medicine is available across the market", "basis": [ "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical claim that the medicine is available across the UAE." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V038", "title": "Two listings more than three days from the claim's date do not bracket it", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing of 9 October 2026 (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-09", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "synthetic": true }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V039", "title": "Listings of two different pharmacies do not bracket a claim's date", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-14, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Another licensed UAE pharmacy's listing of 16 October 2026 (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "another-uae-pharmacy", "showsForSale": true, "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V040", "title": "Two listings both dated before the claim's date do not bracket it", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-15", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-15, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing of 14 October 2026 (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-15", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V041", "title": "Registration does not prove supply: the authorisation supports an availability claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-14, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V042", "title": "A distributor's listing settles availability within its own reach", "basis": [ "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical claim that the medicine is available across the UAE." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "UAE distributor's listing (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-09-01", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "distributor_listing", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V043", "title": "A UAE pharmacy's listing is a foreign record for a Saudi availability claim", "basis": [ "Rule 2", "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical Saudi availability claim." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V044", "title": "A supply record does not establish coverage", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a, example", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical UAE reimbursement claim of 13 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" }, "note": "Version 3.0 divides P6; the claim of reimbursement is P6a. The expected verdict is unchanged: a supply record does not establish coverage." }, { "id": "EAS-V045", "title": "OCTANE: a conference abstract supports an efficacy claim and does not settle it", "basis": [ "section 4, P7, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P7", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Paper No. 01 UAE answer dated 5 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "OCTANE late-breaking abstract, EASD 2026", "evidenceClass": "conference_abstract", "effectiveFrom": "2026-09-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The abstract's date is synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-05", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V046", "title": "OCTANE: a conference abstract supports a reported-result claim and does not settle it", "basis": [ "section 4, P7, example", "section 4, P3c" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3c", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Paper No. 01 UAE answer dated 5 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "OCTANE late-breaking abstract, EASD 2026", "evidenceClass": "conference_abstract", "effectiveFrom": "2026-09-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The abstract's date is synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-05", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V047", "title": "SMARTEST: a registry record neither settles nor supports a comparative claim", "basis": [ "section 4, P9, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P9" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P9", "claim": { "market": [ "SG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-11", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Paper No. 01 Singapore answer dated 11 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "SMARTEST registry record (dapagliflozin compared with metformin)", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2019-01-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The registration date is synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-11", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V048", "title": "A head-to-head trial settles a comparative claim as international evidence", "basis": [ "section 4, P9" ], "illustrates": [ "P9" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "Whether a trial concerns the medicine asked about is another step (section 8).", "input": { "proposition": "P9", "claim": { "market": [ "SG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-11", "synthetic": true, "note": "A Paper No. 01 Singapore answer dated 11 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Head-to-head trial publication (hypothetical: no SMARTEST primary-results publication had been found by 11 October 2026)", "evidenceClass": "head_to_head_trial", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-11", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V049", "title": "A recommendation is never settled: the EDE's announcement is irrelevant to it", "basis": [ "section 4, P10, example", "section 6, Irrelevant", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P10" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P10", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "P10" } }, { "id": "EAS-V050", "title": "The answer change is settled by preserved observations under a longitudinal design", "basis": [ "section 4, the answer change", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "answer_change" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "answer_change", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-22", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim, dated 22 October 2026, that answers about the UAE changed." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Paper No. 01's preserved observations (fixed battery, recorded engine, statistical floor)", "evidenceClass": "longitudinal_observation", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-12", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The date is synthetic. Paper No. 01 records where its own design fell short of the standard's. The observations' market is its UAE arm.", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ] } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-22", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" }, "note": "Version 3.0: observations speak for the markets they observed, so the claim and the observations now state a market; under 2.1 the answer change was judged as international and the vector stated none. The expected verdict is unchanged." }, { "id": "EAS-V051", "title": "A single answer supports an answer-change claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, the answer change" ], "illustrates": [ "answer_change" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "answer_change", "claim": { "market": null, "answerDate": "2026-10-22", "synthetic": true, "note": "A claim, dated 22 October 2026, that answers changed." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "One preserved answer", "evidenceClass": "single_observation", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-22", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V052", "title": "Sotagliflozin: the EU authorisation settles an approval claim dated while it was in force", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2020-06-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 1 June 2020." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Zynquista (sotagliflozin), 26 April 2019, withdrawn 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2020-06-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V053", "title": "Sotagliflozin: the withdrawn authorisation does not settle a claim dated after 22 March 2022", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2023-03-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 1 March 2023." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Zynquista (sotagliflozin), 26 April 2019, withdrawn 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2023-03-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V054", "title": "Sotagliflozin: the authorisation does not settle a claim dated before 26 April 2019", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2019-01-15", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide claim dated 15 January 2019." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Zynquista (sotagliflozin), 26 April 2019, withdrawn 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2019-01-15", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V055", "title": "Sotagliflozin \"approved for type 1\": the label settles the indication claim of its own date", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2021-01-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide indication claim dated 10 January 2021." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Zynquista product information (adjunct to insulin in adults with type 1 diabetes and a BMI of at least 27 kg/m²), in force 26 April 2019 to 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2021-01-10", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V056", "title": "Sotagliflozin: on the withdrawal date the label is no longer in force", "basis": [ "Rule 7, example" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "The withdrawal date is read as the first day the authorisation is no longer in force.", "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2022-03-22", "synthetic": true, "note": "An EU-wide indication claim dated 22 March 2022." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Zynquista product information (adjunct to insulin in adults with type 1 diabetes and a BMI of at least 27 kg/m²), in force 26 April 2019 to 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2022-03-22", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V057", "title": "A claim whose market is unstated is not determinable for a per-market proposition", "basis": [ "Rule 5" ], "illustrates": [ "R5", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": null, "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "An approval claim that names no market." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R5", "market": { "basis": "unresolved", "conflict": false } }, "note": "Version 3.0 adds the market step: no step states a market, so the claim's market is unresolved. The expected verdict is unchanged." }, { "id": "EAS-V058", "title": "A source that does not state its market is not determinable for a per-market proposition", "basis": [ "Rule 5" ], "illustrates": [ "R5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical UAE launch claim." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Manufacturer's dated launch statement that names no market (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "launch_statement", "effectiveFrom": "2026-07-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V059", "title": "A source with no effective date decides nothing for a dated claim", "basis": [ "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "The EDE's announcement, recorded with no date (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": null, "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V060", "title": "A date that is not valid ISO 8601 decides nothing", "basis": [ "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "The EDE's announcement, its date recorded as \"1 June 2026\"", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "1 June 2026", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V061", "title": "A source not yet in force on the claim's date is irrelevant", "basis": [ "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-05-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE approval claim dated 1 May 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-05-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V062", "title": "A supporting source not in force is irrelevant, not supporting: time is checked before class", "basis": [ "section 1", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7", "R6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2024-01-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE approval claim dated 1 January 2024." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Dubai Health Authority document of 3 September 2024 (\"Approved by FDA and registered for obesity pharmacotherapy in UAE\")", "evidenceClass": "institutional_guidance", "authority": "ae_dha", "effectiveFrom": "2024-09-03", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2024-01-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V063", "title": "A stated date later than the answer's own is not the claim's date", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's date", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2027-01", "synthetic": true }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S2-claim-date" } }, { "id": "EAS-V064", "title": "A stated date that is not valid ISO 8601 cannot fix the claim's date", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's date", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "October 2023", "synthetic": true }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S2-claim-date" } }, { "id": "EAS-V065", "title": "A stated date that names the answer's own day leaves the claim's date the answer's", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's date" ], "illustrates": [ "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V066", "title": "An answer with no recorded date has no claim's date", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's date", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": null, "synthetic": true }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S2-claim-date" } }, { "id": "EAS-V067", "title": "A claim that maps to no proposition is not assessable", "basis": [ "section 6, Not determinable" ], "illustrates": [ "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P11", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-proposition" } }, { "id": "EAS-V068", "title": "An authority cited for a class it does not issue, where nothing it issues supports the proposition, is irrelevant", "basis": [ "section 2, Authority", "section 6, Irrelevant" ], "illustrates": [ "R6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "a representative day in the 13 to 16 October 2026 window in which Field Note 07's answers were given" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "An \"authorised label\" attributed to the Dubai Health Authority", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "ae_dha", "effectiveFrom": "2024-09-03", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "S2-authority" } }, { "id": "EAS-V069", "title": "P3d: the registry record version in force states recruiting, so it settles that the study is ongoing", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 March 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic.", "trialStatus": "recruiting" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "settledAs": "ongoing" } }, { "id": "EAS-V070", "title": "P3d: a version stating completed settles that this study was not ongoing (never that no study exists)", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 August 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-08-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic.", "trialStatus": "completed" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "settledAs": "not_ongoing" } }, { "id": "EAS-V071", "title": "P3d: a version that was superseded before the claim's date is not in force on it", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 January 2025, superseded 1 March 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2025-01-01", "effectiveTo": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic.", "trialStatus": "recruiting" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V072", "title": "P3d: a version that states no overall status settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "P3", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 March 2026, no status recorded", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P3d" } }, { "id": "EAS-V073", "title": "P3d: a version whose status is unknown settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "P3", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 March 2026, status unknown", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic.", "trialStatus": "unknown" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P3d" } }, { "id": "EAS-V074", "title": "P3d: a manufacturer's statement supports and never settles that a study is ongoing", "basis": [ "section 4, P3d" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3d", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Manufacturer's pipeline page listing the study (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "manufacturer_statement", "effectiveFrom": "2026-09-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V075", "title": "P3 is settled through P3d and P2: a registry record alone, even of an ongoing study, only supports it", "basis": [ "section 4, P3" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "synthetic": true, "note": "A UAE answer dated 1 October 2026 saying the study is ongoing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Registry record of an interventional study of the medicine for the use asked about (hypothetical), version posted 1 March 2026", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study, its versions and their dates are synthetic.", "trialStatus": "recruiting" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V076", "title": "P8a: the claim's market's authorised label settles a regulatory safety statement", "basis": [ "section 4, P8a" ], "illustrates": [ "P8a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "US" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "A US regulatory safety claim dated 8 October 2026." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision, warnings and precautions", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V077", "title": "P8a: another market's label is a declared benchmark for a regulatory safety statement", "basis": [ "section 4, P8a", "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "P8a", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V078", "title": "P8a: the regulator's own safety communication settles a regulatory safety statement for its market", "basis": [ "section 4, P8a" ], "illustrates": [ "P8a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "SFDA safety communication (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "regulator_safety_communication", "authority": "sa_sfda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V079", "title": "P8a: a systematic review cannot say what a label carries", "basis": [ "section 4, P8a" ], "illustrates": [ "P8a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Systematic review of teplizumab safety (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "systematic_review", "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V080", "title": "P8b: an authorised label supports a safety finding and never settles it, from any market", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "US Tzield prescribing information, June 2026 revision", "evidenceClass": "authorised_label", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V081", "title": "P8b: a regulator's safety communication supports a safety finding and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "SFDA safety communication (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "regulator_safety_communication", "authority": "sa_sfda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V082", "title": "P8b: a case report supports a safety finding and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Case report (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "case_report_or_forum", "effectiveFrom": "2026-07-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V083", "title": "\"P8\" is no longer a proposition id: a claim mapped to it is not assessable", "basis": [ "section 3", "section 6, Not determinable" ], "illustrates": [ "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Systematic review of teplizumab safety (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "systematic_review", "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-proposition" } }, { "id": "EAS-V084", "title": "A pharmacy listing that does not show the product for sale settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "P5", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing of 13 October 2026, product shown as not for sale (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": false, "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V085", "title": "A supply record that does not say which record it is settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Rule 8" ], "illustrates": [ "P5", "R8" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "UAE supply record of 13 October 2026, kind not recorded (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V086", "title": "A listing on the claim's own date only supports a claim that the medicine is available across the market", "basis": [ "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical claim, dated 13 October 2026, that the medicine is available across the UAE." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V087", "title": "Two bracketing listings, one not showing the product for sale, settle nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-14, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing of 16 October 2026, product shown as not for sale (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": false, "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V088", "title": "Two listings judged together where one is dated the claim's date: that listing is judged on its own, and settles", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "note": "Section 4, P5: a listing dated the claim's date is judged on its own. Field Note 07's 9 answers given on 13 or 16 October are settled by the listing of their day.", "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V089", "title": "The same pair for a 16 October answer: the 16 October listing is judged on its own, and settles", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-16", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-16, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-16", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V090", "title": "A same-day listing judged on its own keeps its own verdict: one not showing the product for sale settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A \"not available in the UAE\" answer given on 2026-10-13, a day in the published 13 to 16 October window." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing of 13 October 2026, product shown as not for sale (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": false, "synthetic": true }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V091", "title": "A same-day listing judged on its own only supports a claim of market-wide availability", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "A hypothetical claim, dated 13 October 2026, that the medicine is available across the UAE." }, "evidence": { "judged": "bracketed", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." }, { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 16 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-16", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V092", "title": "P8b: a trial's publication of record supports a safety finding and does not settle it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Publication of record of a teplizumab trial (hypothetical)", "evidenceClass": "trial_publication_of_record", "effectiveFrom": "2025-06-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V093", "title": "P8b: a regulator's assessment report supports a safety finding and does not settle it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-08", "synthetic": true, "note": "8 October 2026, the date of the Paper No. 01 Saudi-arm answer section 4 (P8) cites; used for the arm's other claims too" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EMA assessment report for Teizeild (hypothetical date)", "evidenceClass": "regulator_assessment_report", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-08", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V094", "title": "The question's market fixes the claim's market when the answer states none", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M2" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": null, "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"Not approved or sold\", in an answer to a UAE question." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "question", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V095", "title": "The deploying system's declared market fixes it when neither the answer nor the question states one", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M3" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": null, "questionMarket": null, "configuredMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "A deployment declared for UAE users; the question names no market." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "configuration", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V096", "title": "The answer's market governs over the question's, and the conflict is recorded", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M1", "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "An answer that says \"approved in Saudi Arabia\" to a UAE question makes a Saudi claim." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": true } } }, { "id": "EAS-V097", "title": "A declared market never overrides the question's", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M3" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": null, "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "configuredMarket": [ "SA" ], "note": "A UAE question in a deployment declared for Saudi users." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "question", "conflict": true } } }, { "id": "EAS-V098", "title": "\"Worldwide\" in the answer stops the market step: the question's market is not taken instead", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M6", "Rule 5" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step", "R5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": "worldwide", "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"Approved worldwide\", in an answer to a UAE question." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R5", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": true } }, "note": "The answer step governs and states a market word that names no market: the market is unresolved (codes null) and the basis is the answer." }, { "id": "EAS-V099", "title": "For a proposition settled internationally, the market is recorded and does not govern", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M7", "section 4, P3a" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": null, "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"The trial is registered\", in an answer to a UAE question." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a trial registry record", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2025-01-10", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "question", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V100", "title": "P6a: a payer decision that covers the market's population settles a claim of coverage in the market", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Reimbursed in Saudi Arabia\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: market)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "market", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V101", "title": "P6a: one payer's or plan's decision supports, and never settles, a claim of coverage across the market", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Reimbursed in Saudi Arabia\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: scheme)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "scheme", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P6a" } }, { "id": "EAS-V102", "title": "P6a: one payer's or plan's decision settles a claim that names that payer", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "p6aScope": "named_payer", "note": "\"Covered by [the named insurer]\"; that the decision is that insurer's is interpretation." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: scheme)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "scheme", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V103", "title": "P6a: a payer decision that does not state its reach settles nothing", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Reimbursed in Saudi Arabia\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance, reach not stated", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "P6a" } }, { "id": "EAS-V104", "title": "P6a: an HTA recommendation supports a claim of reimbursement and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a and P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "GB" ], "note": "\"Reimbursed in the United Kingdom\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a health technology assessment body's published appraisal", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V105", "title": "P6b: the HTA body's own appraisal settles its recommendation, for the jurisdiction it speaks for", "basis": [ "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "P6b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "GB" ], "note": "\"Recommended by the HTA body in the United Kingdom\": the appraisal speaks for the United Kingdom. A body whose remit is one country of the United Kingdom speaks for that country only (Annex B, M1 and M6; EAS-V155 and EAS-V156)." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a health technology assessment body's published appraisal", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" }, "note": "Version 3.0, sharpened before release: places below the country are recorded by ISO 3166-2 codes, and a source whose reach is a subdivision never settles a claim about the country. This vector's appraisal speaks for the United Kingdom as a whole, so its expected verdict is unchanged; its claim note no longer calls the sub-national question open." }, { "id": "EAS-V106", "title": "P6b: another jurisdiction's appraisal is a declared benchmark", "basis": [ "section 4, P6b", "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "P6b", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "A Saudi recommendation claim judged against a UK appraisal." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a health technology assessment body's published appraisal", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V107", "title": "P6b: a payer's decision does not establish an HTA recommendation", "basis": [ "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "P6b", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Recommended by the HTA body\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: market)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "market", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V108", "title": "P6c: a named formulary's own listing settles that the medicine is on it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6c" ], "illustrates": [ "P6c" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"On [the named hospital]'s formulary\": the formulary's own stated scope governs." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a named hospital formulary's listing", "evidenceClass": "formulary_listing", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-15", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V109", "title": "P6c: a payer's decision supports a formulary claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6c" ], "illustrates": [ "P6c", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"On [a named insurer]'s formulary\": the claim names the formulary." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: market)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "market", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" }, "note": "Version 3.0, sharpened before release: a formulary the sentence does not name (\"on the formulary\") makes a P6c claim that no source can be matched to, which is not determinable (EAS-V148). This vector's claim now names the formulary, so it tests what it was written to test, that a payer's decision supports a formulary claim; its expected verdict is unchanged." }, { "id": "EAS-V110", "title": "\"P6\" is no longer a proposition id: a claim mapped to it is not assessable", "basis": [ "section 4, P6", "section 6" ], "illustrates": [ "S6-proposition" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "A claim mapped to the retired id." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: market)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "market", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-proposition" } }, { "id": "EAS-V111", "title": "P8c: a regulator's signal record settles that a signal was raised, wherever the claim was asked", "basis": [ "section 4, P8c" ], "illustrates": [ "P8c" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Regulators are assessing reports of [an adverse effect]\", in a Saudi answer." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a European Medicines Agency signal assessment record", "evidenceClass": "safety_signal_record", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2026-07-07", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V112", "title": "P8c: a regulator's safety communication announcing a review settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8c" ], "illustrates": [ "P8c" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"The Saudi regulator is reviewing [an adverse effect]\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a Saudi Food and Drug Authority safety communication", "evidenceClass": "regulator_safety_communication", "authority": "sa_sfda", "effectiveFrom": "2026-08-02", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V113", "title": "P8b: a signal record supports a safety finding and never settles it: a signal is not causation", "basis": [ "section 4, P8b and P8c" ], "illustrates": [ "P8b", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"The medicine causes [the adverse effect]\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a European Medicines Agency signal assessment record", "evidenceClass": "safety_signal_record", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2026-07-07", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V114", "title": "P8c: a systematic review does not say that a body raised a signal", "basis": [ "section 4, P8c" ], "illustrates": [ "P8c", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Regulators are assessing reports of [an adverse effect]\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a systematic review", "evidenceClass": "systematic_review", "effectiveFrom": "2025-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V115", "title": "P8c: a body that does not issue signal records settles nothing as one", "basis": [ "section 4, P8c", "section 2, Authority", "Rule 6" ], "illustrates": [ "P8c", "S2-authority" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "note": "A signal record attributed to the Dubai Health Authority." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a record attributed to the Dubai Health Authority", "evidenceClass": "safety_signal_record", "authority": "ae_dha", "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "S2-authority" } }, { "id": "EAS-V116", "title": "The answer change: observations of one market are a declared benchmark for another", "basis": [ "section 4, the answer change", "Rule 2" ], "illustrates": [ "answer_change", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "answer_change", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "A claim that answers about Saudi Arabia changed, judged against observations of UAE answers." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: preserved observations of UAE answers (fixed battery, recorded engine, statistical floor)", "evidenceClass": "longitudinal_observation", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-12", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V117", "title": "P6a: a decision that covers the market's population also settles a claim naming that payer", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "p6aScope": "named_payer", "note": "\"Covered by [the named insurer]\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance (reach: market)", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": "market", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V118", "title": "The answer change with no market stated anywhere is not determinable: it is settled per market", "basis": [ "section 4, the answer change", "Rule 5" ], "illustrates": [ "answer_change", "R5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "answer_change", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": null, "note": "\"AI answers about this medicine changed\", with no market in the answer, the question or the configuration. Under 2.1 the answer change was judged as international." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: preserved observations of UAE answers (fixed battery, recorded engine, statistical floor)", "evidenceClass": "longitudinal_observation", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-12", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "R5", "market": { "basis": "unresolved", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V119", "title": "P8c: a regulator's assessment report supports a safety-signal claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P8c" ], "illustrates": [ "P8c", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P8c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "SA" ], "note": "\"Regulators are assessing reports of [an adverse effect]\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a European Medicines Agency assessment report", "evidenceClass": "regulator_assessment_report", "authority": "eu_ema", "effectiveFrom": "2026-05-04", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V120", "title": "P5: an availability claim with no word of breadth takes the first claim form, which a same-day listing settles", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Annex B, C6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "note": "\"Available in the UAE\", classified under C6 as the first claim form. Under 2.1 such a claim had no form and a listing only supported it." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a licensed UAE pharmacy's listing dated 14 October 2026, showing the product for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "hypothetical-uae-pharmacy", "showsForSale": true, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V121", "title": "The answer and the question state the same market: no conflict", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M1" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"Approved in the UAE\", in an answer to a UAE question." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: emirates Drug Establishment approval", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V122", "title": "P6b: a manufacturer's statement supports an HTA recommendation claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "P6b", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "GB" ], "note": "\"Recommended by the national HTA body\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a manufacturer's statement", "evidenceClass": "manufacturer_statement", "jurisdictions": [ "GB" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V123", "title": "P6c: commentary supports a formulary claim and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6c" ], "illustrates": [ "P6c", "R1" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6c", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"On [a named hospital]'s formulary\"." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: press commentary", "evidenceClass": "secondary_commentary", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-10", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V124", "title": "T7: an answer captured on 14 October in the UAE is judged on 14 October, whatever the instant in UTC", "basis": [ "Annex B, T7", "section 7", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "T7", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14T02:30:00+04:00", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "note": "Captured at 02:30 in the UAE on 14 October, 22:30 on 13 October in UTC." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a licensed UAE pharmacy's listing dated 14 October 2026, showing the product for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "hypothetical-uae-pharmacy", "showsForSale": true, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V125", "title": "T4: an earlier time given without a date leaves the claim's date not determinable", "basis": [ "Annex B, T4", "section 2, the claim's date" ], "illustrates": [ "T4", "S2-claim-date" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "AE" ], "statedDateUndetermined": true, "note": "\"As of my last update, it is not approved in the UAE.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: emirates Drug Establishment approval", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S2-claim-date" } }, { "id": "EAS-V126", "title": "P6b: naming the assessment body states its market, which governs over the question's", "basis": [ "section 2, the claim's market", "Annex B, M1", "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step", "P6b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "market": [ "GB" ], "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "note": "\"Recommended by [a UK HTA body]\", in an answer to a UAE question: the body's market is the answer's (M1)." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a health technology assessment body's published appraisal", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": true } } }, { "id": "EAS-V127", "title": "An event claim is settled by the record of the event issued by the answer's date, whatever the date it gives for the event", "basis": [ "Annex B, T6", "Rule 7", "section 4, P2, example" ], "illustrates": [ "T6", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2026-01", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Teplizumab was approved in the EU in January 2026\": an event claim, whose claim's date is the stated month. Read as a state, the decision of 8 January 2026 is not in force throughout the month and would settle nothing." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-01", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V128", "title": "An event claim is settled by the record of the event although the authorisation was later withdrawn", "basis": [ "Rule 7", "Annex B, T6" ], "illustrates": [ "T6", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2019-04", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Sotagliflozin was approved in the EU in April 2019\", in an answer of October 2026: the example Rule 7 gives." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Zynquista (sotagliflozin), 26 April 2019, withdrawn on 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2019-04", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V129", "title": "An event claim is not settled by a record annulled as to the event before the answer's date", "basis": [ "Rule 7", "Annex B, T6" ], "illustrates": [ "T6", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2026-03", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Approved in the UAE in March 2026\", against a decision later annulled as to that grant." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an Emirates Drug Establishment authorisation decision of 10 March 2026, annulled on 1 July 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-10", "annulledOn": "2026-07-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-03", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V130", "title": "An event claim: a record issued after the answer's date does not settle it", "basis": [ "Annex B, T6", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "T6", "R7" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2025-12-20", "statedDate": "2025-12", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Approved in the EU in December 2025\", in an answer of 20 December 2025: the Commission's decision of 8 January 2026 came later." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2025-12", "verdict": "irrelevant", "rule": "R7" } }, { "id": "EAS-V131", "title": "An event claim keeps its stated period even where the period contains the answer's date", "basis": [ "Annex B, T2", "Annex B, T6" ], "illustrates": [ "T2", "T6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2026-10", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Approved in the UAE in October 2026\", in an answer of 14 October 2026: the claim's date stays the month." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an Emirates Drug Establishment authorisation decision dated 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V132", "title": "A past-tense event with no time stated is an undated event claim, dated the answer's date and settled by a record issued by then", "basis": [ "Annex B, T6", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "T6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "dateKind": "undated_event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Sotagliflozin was approved in the EU\", stating no time: the record's date is compared with any time on or before the answer's date." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Zynquista (sotagliflozin), 26 April 2019, withdrawn on 22 March 2022", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2019-04-26", "effectiveTo": "2022-03-22", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V133", "title": "An event claim: a register copy settles the date it records for the event whatever its currency on the answer's date", "basis": [ "Rule 7", "Rule 3", "section 4, P1, example", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "T6", "R3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2022-11-14", "dateKind": "event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"The injection was registered in the UAE on 14 November 2022.\" Rule 3 bounds claims about a state: the copy's currency, evidenced to 5 October, does not bound an event claim." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: the injection, registered 14 November 2022, as recorded on 2 and 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2022-11-14", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "Registration date and reading as section 4 (P1) reports them. currentAsOf is synthetic: the latest date the directory copy is taken to vouch for, the day of the 5 October read. Whether the value was read correctly is another step (section 8); Field Note 07 could not re-read it on 19 October 2026." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2022-11-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V134", "title": "An event placed in a month with no year is an undated event claim, settled by a record issued by the answer's date", "basis": [ "Annex B, T6", "Rule 7" ], "illustrates": [ "T6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "dateKind": "undated_event", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Approved in the EU in January\", naming no year: the words are recorded for adjudication." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V135", "title": "A past-tense state with no time stated leaves the claim's date not determinable", "basis": [ "Annex B, T6", "Annex B, T4" ], "illustrates": [ "T4", "T6" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "statedDateUndetermined": true, "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It was available in the UAE\": a state placed at an earlier time without a date." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": null, "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S2-claim-date" } }, { "id": "EAS-V136", "title": "A stated period that contains the answer's date is read as the answer's date, for a claim that dates a state", "basis": [ "Annex B, T2", "section 2, the claim's date" ], "illustrates": [ "T2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2026-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"As of October 2026\", in an answer of 14 October 2026: the answer cannot speak for the rest of the month. Read as the month, a decision of 5 October would not be in force throughout it." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an Emirates Drug Establishment authorisation decision dated 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V137", "title": "P5, named channel: the regulator's published rules for an access route, which name no medicine, support a claim about the route and never settle it", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Annex B, C6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "named_channel", "p5Channel": "regulatory_route", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It can be obtained in the UAE through a named-patient import route.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: the Emirates Drug Establishment's published rules for named-patient import, naming no medicine", "evidenceClass": "institutional_guidance", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2025-03-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V138", "title": "P5, named channel: the regulator's import permit naming the medicine settles a claim about the route", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Annex B, C6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "named_channel", "p5Channel": "regulatory_route", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It can be obtained in the UAE through a named-patient import route.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an Emirates Drug Establishment import permit naming the medicine, under its named-patient route", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-02-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V139", "title": "P5, named channel: a named supplier's own listing, dated the claim's date, settles a claim about that supplier", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Annex B, C6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "named_channel", "p5Channel": "supplier", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It can be bought at [the named pharmacy chain]\"; that the listing is that chain's is interpretation." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V140", "title": "P5, named channel: a claim that does not record the channel's kind is not determinable", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "named_channel", "synthetic": true, "note": "A named-channel claim recorded without saying whether the channel is a regulatory access route or a supplier." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-no-source" } }, { "id": "EAS-V141", "title": "P5: a negative claim about a channel named only by kind is not determinable", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6", "Annex B, C6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "channel_kind", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is not dispensed by pharmacies in the UAE.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-no-source" } }, { "id": "EAS-V142", "title": "P5, stock: a claim about stock is settled by no class, so it is not determinable", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "section 6", "Annex B, C6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "stock", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is out of stock in the UAE.\" A listing is not proof of stock." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-no-source" } }, { "id": "EAS-V143", "title": "P5: a claim that the medicine is not available across the market is the negation of the across-market form, which a listing only supports", "basis": [ "section 4, P5", "Annex B, C6", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-13", "p5Scope": "across_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is not widely available in the UAE.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Licensed UAE pharmacy chain listing read on 13 October 2026, injection and tablet shown for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-13", "currency": "assured", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "fn07-uae-pharmacy-chain", "showsForSale": true, "note": "One licensed UAE pharmacy chain's listing, as Field Note 07 read it; the pharmacy identifier is this file's." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-13", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P5" } }, { "id": "EAS-V144", "title": "P2: the authorisation decision settles a claim about the legal category of supply", "basis": [ "section 4, P2", "Annex B, C2", "section 4, P2, example" ], "illustrates": [ "P2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p2Term": "legal_category", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Teizeild is a prescription-only medicine in the EU\": Annex II to the Commission's decision states the legal category." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V145", "title": "P2: the authorisation decision settles a claim about a restricted programme the authorisation requires", "basis": [ "section 4, P2", "Annex B, C2", "Annex B, C6" ], "illustrates": [ "P2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "US" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p2Term": "restricted_programme", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"In the US it is available only through the [name] REMS Program\": a condition of the authorisation, P2." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an FDA approval that requires a REMS for every supply", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "us_fda", "effectiveFrom": "2025-06-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V146", "title": "P2: the authorisation decision supports a claim about the authorised dose and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P2", "Annex B, C2" ], "illustrates": [ "P2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P2", "claim": { "market": [ "AT", "BE", "BG", "HR", "CY", "CZ", "DK", "EE", "FI", "FR", "DE", "GR", "HU", "IE", "IT", "LV", "LT", "LU", "MT", "NL", "PL", "PT", "RO", "SK", "SI", "ES", "SE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p2Term": "dose", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"In the EU it is approved at [a stated dose]\": only the label settles a dose." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "European Commission authorisation of Teizeild (teplizumab), 8 January 2026", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "eu_ec", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-08", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R1" } }, { "id": "EAS-V147", "title": "P4: a recommendation attributed to guidelines the claim does not identify is not determinable", "basis": [ "section 4, P4", "section 6", "Annex B, C12", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P4" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P4", "claim": { "market": [ "SG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-05", "sourceUnidentified": true, "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Guidelines recommend it first-line\": the claim identifies no guideline, so even the consensus Paper No. 01 used as its reference frame cannot be matched to it." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "2022 ADA/EASD consensus report on type 2 diabetes", "evidenceClass": "clinical_guideline", "effectiveFrom": "2022", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-05", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-no-source" } }, { "id": "EAS-V148", "title": "P6c: a formulary the claim does not name is not determinable", "basis": [ "section 4, P6c", "section 6", "Annex B, C9" ], "illustrates": [ "P6c" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6c", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "sourceUnidentified": true, "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is on the formulary\", naming none." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a named hospital formulary's listing", "evidenceClass": "formulary_listing", "effectiveFrom": "2026-01-15", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "not_determinable", "rule": "S6-no-source" } }, { "id": "EAS-V149", "title": "P3 with no use named is still composite, settled through P3d and P1; a registry record alone only supports it", "basis": [ "section 4, P3", "Annex B, C10", "Paper No. 01" ], "illustrates": [ "P3" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P3", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-01", "useNamed": false, "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Retatrutide is investigational\", naming no use: its parts are an ongoing study (P3d) and no marketing authorisation in the UAE (P1)." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Trial registry record of an interventional retatrutide study", "evidenceClass": "trial_registry_record", "effectiveFrom": "2023-05-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "The study and its registration date are synthetic." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-01", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P3" } }, { "id": "EAS-V150", "title": "A claim about a place below the country is settled by its country's regulator; the subdivision and the country are different markets", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Rule 2", "section 2, the claim's market", "section 4, P1, example" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step", "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE-DU" ], "questionMarket": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is approved in Dubai\", in an answer to a UAE question: the answer's market, Dubai (AE-DU), governs, and differs from the question's." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Emirates Drug Establishment announcement of 1 June 2026 approving the oral form", "evidenceClass": "authorisation_decision", "authority": "ae_ede", "effectiveFrom": "2026-06-01", "currency": "assured" } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": true } } }, { "id": "EAS-V151", "title": "A national register entry settles a registration claim about an emirate", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Rule 2", "section 4, P1, example", "Field Note 07" ], "illustrates": [ "R2" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P1", "claim": { "market": [ "AE-DU" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "statedDate": "2023-10", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"As of October 2023, it was registered in Dubai.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "EDE directory: the injection, registered 14 November 2022, as recorded on 2 and 5 October 2026", "evidenceClass": "register_entry", "authority": "ae_ede", "reading": "listed", "effectiveFrom": "2022-11-14", "currency": "not_assured", "currentAsOf": "2026-10-05", "synthetic": true, "note": "Registration date and reading as section 4 (P1) reports them. currentAsOf is synthetic: the latest date the directory copy is taken to vouch for, the day of the 5 October read. Whether the value was read correctly is another step (section 8); Field Note 07 could not re-read it on 19 October 2026." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2023-10", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V152", "title": "A national launch statement supports, and never settles, a claim about one emirate", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Rule 2", "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "R2", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE-FU" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is available in Fujairah.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a manufacturer's statement that the product has launched in the UAE", "evidenceClass": "launch_statement", "jurisdictions": [ "AE" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-07-01", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V153", "title": "A Dubai pharmacy listing dated the claim's date settles a claim that the medicine is not available anywhere in the UAE", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Rule 2", "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "R2", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is not available anywhere in the UAE.\" A listing speaks for its own place and every place that contains it." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a licensed Dubai pharmacy's listing dated 14 October 2026, showing the product for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "hypothetical-dubai-pharmacy", "showsForSale": true, "jurisdictions": [ "AE-DU" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V154", "title": "A Dubai pharmacy listing does not settle a claim about Abu Dhabi", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Rule 2", "section 4, P5" ], "illustrates": [ "R2", "P5" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "AE-AZ" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is not available anywhere in Abu Dhabi.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a licensed Dubai pharmacy's listing dated 14 October 2026, showing the product for sale", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "supplyKind": "pharmacy_listing", "pharmacy": "hypothetical-dubai-pharmacy", "showsForSale": true, "jurisdictions": [ "AE-DU" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-10-14", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V155", "title": "A body whose reach is part of a country never settles a claim about the country", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Annex B, M1", "Rule 2", "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "R2", "P6b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "market": [ "GB" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Recommended in the United Kingdom\", judged against an appraisal for England." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an appraisal by a health technology assessment body whose remit is England", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB-ENG" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "R2" } }, { "id": "EAS-V156", "title": "A body whose reach is part of a country settles a claim about that part", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "Annex B, M1", "section 4, P6b" ], "illustrates": [ "P6b" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6b", "claim": { "market": [ "GB-ENG" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"In the UK, [the body for England] recommends it\": naming the body states England (M1)." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: an appraisal by a health technology assessment body whose remit is England", "evidenceClass": "hta_appraisal", "jurisdictions": [ "GB-ENG" ], "effectiveFrom": "2025-11-05", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V157", "title": "A place with both an ISO 3166-1 and an ISO 3166-2 code is recorded by its ISO 3166-2 code", "basis": [ "Annex B, M6", "section 2, the claim's market" ], "illustrates": [ "market_step" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P5", "claim": { "market": [ "PR" ], "questionMarket": [ "US-PR" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p5Scope": "anywhere_in_market", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"It is sold in Puerto Rico\": PR and US-PR are one place, so the answer and the question state the same market." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a distributor's listing in Puerto Rico", "evidenceClass": "supply_record", "supplyKind": "distributor_listing", "jurisdictions": [ "US-PR" ], "effectiveFrom": "2026-09-01", "effectiveTo": "2026-12-31", "currency": "assured", "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles", "market": { "basis": "answer", "conflict": false } } }, { "id": "EAS-V158", "title": "P6a: a payer's reach stated as a place below the country settles a claim of coverage in that place", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a", "Annex B, M6" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA-01" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Covered in the Riyadh region.\"" }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance whose reach is the Riyadh region", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": { "places": [ "SA-01" ] }, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } }, { "id": "EAS-V159", "title": "P6a: a payer's reach that covers part of the claim's market supports a claim of coverage across it and never settles it", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a", "Annex B, M6" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Covered in Saudi Arabia\", judged against a decision whose reach is one region." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance whose reach is the Riyadh region", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": { "places": [ "SA-01" ] }, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P6a" } }, { "id": "EAS-V160", "title": "P6a: a decision covering part of a place's population is one plan's decision, which supports a claim of coverage in the place", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a", "Annex B, M6" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA-01" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Covered in the Riyadh region\", judged against a decision for one group of its residents." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance whose reach is government employees in the Riyadh region", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": { "places": [ "SA-01" ], "population": "government employees" }, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "supports", "rule": "P6a" } }, { "id": "EAS-V161", "title": "P6a: a decision covering part of a place's population settles a claim that names the plan", "basis": [ "section 4, P6a", "Annex B, M6", "Annex B, M1" ], "illustrates": [ "P6a" ], "synthetic": true, "input": { "proposition": "P6a", "claim": { "market": [ "SA-01" ], "answerDate": "2026-10-14", "p6aScope": "named_payer", "synthetic": true, "note": "\"Covered by [the named plan]\"; that the decision is that plan's is interpretation." }, "evidence": { "judged": "single", "sources": [ { "label": "Hypothetical: a coverage decision of the Council of Health Insurance whose reach is government employees in the Riyadh region", "evidenceClass": "payer_decision", "authority": "sa_chi", "effectiveFrom": "2026-03-01", "currency": "assured", "payerReach": { "places": [ "SA-01" ], "population": "government employees" }, "synthetic": true, "note": "Hypothetical: the record, its issuer's issuing of it and its date are this file's; no such record is asserted to exist." } ] } }, "expected": { "claimDate": "2026-10-14", "verdict": "settles", "rule": "S6-settles" } } ] }